Pages Menu
Categories Menu

Posted by on Jun 11, 2015 in WhoDunIt |

The Vandalizing Visitor

The Vandalizing Visitor

It was late at night at the Drakemore Hotel. A member of the cleaning staff was dusting the courtesy phones in the lobby when she heard the breaking of glass in the side lobby. And then the alarm went off.

The side lobby contained a display case holding memorabilia from the Drakemore’s opening fifty years ago: the hotel’s first menu, a laughably antiquated price list for rooms, a few rare coins and stamps from that year, photographs, and the dusty signatures of the first famous guests.

The night manager showed up a few seconds later. He and the staff member circled the lobby and discovered three guests who had been in the vicinity. Diplomatically but firmly, the manager suggested all three remain in the lobby until the police arrived.

“We’ve had them under constant observation’ the manager told the responding officer. He pointed to a woman reading in an arm chair. “Ms. Oakley said she had just returned from a business dinner. She was very cooperative. Just sat down and pulled a book out of her briefcase.”

“Mr. Brier said he’d come down from his room to get some aspirin from the front desk. His wife had a headache. When we detained him, he called his wife on one of the pay phones. I listened in. He told her he would be delayed and not to worry.”

The manager pointed to the last suspect, a sloppily dressed young man who looked like he’d had one too many. “Mr. Greenleaf had been in the hotel bar. The bartender refused to serve him any more alcohol, so he wandered in here. We found him by the elevator, jamming his finger into the ‘up’ button.”

“Whoever did this wasn’t counting on an alarm’ the manager continued. “Perhaps he was scared off before he took anything. We may never know who tried to rob us.” “I have a good idea who it was,” the officer said. “One of the suspects did something odd. Just let me have one thing checked.”


Question: Whom does the officer suspect and why?

Answer: The officer was struck by the fact that the second suspect, Mr. Brier, had used a pay phone to call his room instead of one of the courtesy phones. When a service technician from the telephone company opened the phone’s coin box, he found a rare old quarter. Mr. Brier had stolen the quarter from the display case. Using the pay phone was the only way he could think of to get rid of the incriminating coin.